Review based on ARC.
I love Grimm and I was very excited to win a copy of Modern Grimmoire. Not really sure what to expect -- would these be new takes on old stories? new stories? It was a combination. A very dark, very angry combination of, as the subtitle states, fairy tales, fables and folklore.
Overall, I was very happy with the anthology. It was a quick read, and each story very comfortably stands on its own. I would recommend to anyone who has a penchant for all things Grimm, for people who are interested in dark fairy tales, folklore, and fables, and for those with a stomach for the, well, grim. In other words, if the title is appealing to you, go ahead and pick it up. The book does the title and the cover justice.
Again, overall, FOUR of five stars.
The anthology is comprised of mostly stories, a few poems, and a handful of pictures, each of the stories I review below (reviews, not synopses.. they are short so summarizing practically retells the story, which is unfair and unnecessary):
- The Ex-Court Painter, Goya, and the Princess was one of the highlights of the anthology. It tells teh story of an ex-royal painter, who is called into court to do a particularly sensitive and confidential job for the King. The painter is shuffled down to the basement, and is locked in a room to do his work. I will not spoil what the painting is of or how the story progresses, but the story had the flavor of classic Grimm, with its own dark twists. The characters were well portrayed, even in the few pages, and the story was intriguing and complete.
- Night People, in Summer. I think this was my favorite. I loved the magical realism aspect of this one, and I thought the tone was just right for a slightly creepy, slightly nostalgic Grimm. The author took the ordinary life and added not only magic and supernatural intrigue, but also a light element of danger. I wouldn't mind seeing this "ghost" story in longer form some day.
- The Black Widow. This one was incredibly creepy, very well written, very creepy. Did I say creepy twice? I talked about this one to everyone who would listen while I was reading it. It stayed with me while I was hiking a beautiful trail in Taos NM. It was very well written, and completely brought the reader into the folds (or, should I say, web?) of the story effortlessly.
- Isle in Man: This was interesting and, again, really well done. This is the kind of story that could be blossomed into a novel or even a movie. It's kind of super-hero'y and kind of X-Men'y, with a lot of heart. It leaves the reader with a lot of questions, and with a desire to know what happend NEXT? and BEFORE? The title didn't really do the tale justice... not that I can think of a better one, I just didn't like it as a match to the story.
- Something Gold: Oh this was very well done. I love how the author started each new phase with the same phrase. I love how the tale was unsettling and squirmy. I love the quick but not choppy progression from one phase to the next. I didn't love the end as much, but I appreciated that there WAS an end... some sense of closure (without actual closure... just the prediction of one).
- Gourmaundeth: I am not sure why the typefont was formatted the way it was. This was almost more poem than it was story. I think the formatting was to show the disjointed, choppy thinking of the narrator. Which worked. It gave the story a lack of direction and a confusion that worked for the ultimate story. While I didn't love this one, it definitely did fit in the anthology and did not detract from the mood.
- The Mirror Child: this is another story with great ambiance and tone. I loved the fairy tale'ness of this story. It had a classic feel to it, while adding the new twist. Although I felt that the ending was a little convenient, I also appreciated it. Overall, a great story with a neat little "package" epilogue at the end.
- The Music Box: Fun. This one was a fun tale - I loved the light heartedness aspect, the modern-day relatability to dating. and the cute twist at the end.
- Fish: This was an interesting concept -- take the marriage of a mermaid to a human, and tell it from the mermaid's perspective. I thought it was just heartbreaking enough, and just hopeful enough. Another one that I would enjoy seeing developed into a novella or even a novel.
- Bury me in Faerie: This story was a sad story, but, again, had a hopeful air to it. Throughout the story and even at the end, there is the air of possibility. And although the characters are grieving and their lives seem difficult and sad, there is hope. It was a nice little story. Not my favorite, but sweet.
- Arowana: I felt that this was a story with a lot of promise, a lot of interesting and intriguing concepts, and I just did not love the direction it ultimately took. This one probably falls more squarely under "Fable" than the others, so the path makes sense. It just fell a little for me, turning from a story with great promise, to a lesson, perhaps well learned.
- Starlight!: This story was flippant and had an undertone of cruel to it. The characters are almost completely non-endearing, but intentionally so. The perspective is almost that of making the exalted humdrum. I guess I did not love this one because I felt that perhaps it went just a little too humdrum. No point to the story other than to say, hey, maybe these kings and queens, they're just like us. Interesting concept, but I would like liked even a little bit of a plot.
Detours: A Suburban Fairy Tale: I really enjoyed this one. It had questions that were raised throughout. Some of the questions were kind of answered, but the mystery of the characters was kept and relished. I really enjoyed how this one "ended" - I am impressed with an author who can end a short story well, and this one accomplished it.
Catspaw: I enjoyed this tale and the overall story that was told. It is another that felt more classic in tone. I was a little annoyed while reading it, even though I both appreciated the possible alternative paths and even though I completely understood what the author was doing and why. I just like reading stories. Ultimately, after I had read the whole story, however, it WAS complete, a story well told, and an ending that I could appreciate.
- The Wolfman's New Gig: Cute. At first I was confused about what was happening, which was intentional and well done. The progression of the story, the very modern and very real elements of marriage and relationship that were interjected, and the conclusion that took it right back to Grimm were all very well coordinated. The building up of the characters was expertly done, with every new action taken both a complete surprise and completely expected. This is another one of the standouts in the anthology.
- Persuasion: very disturbing. Definitely a modern, dark twist on the classic tale. It was well done, but I did not love it.
- Henry's Tale: I liked this slightly feminist twist on the classic Hansel & Gretel. It was almost like reading a "this is what REALLY happened" of the story, which seemed to explain the motivations, actions, and perspectives of the original tale even better. I really liked his Gerta.
- The Storyteller's Jig: This felt like an intro to a story. A very interesting story, but just an intro. At the end of the tale, I was just left wanting to know something, ANYTHING, about what supposedly happened next. Is the man safe? is he human? is the story good? do kids die? does anything happen???? I felt like there were TOO many questions left unanswered -- to the extent that it just wasn't a story. As I said, just an intro. But the writing style was good... otherwise, I wouldn't have any questions, would I...
- Through the Diamond Blues: This story was a very innocent simple tale. The "villain" is sweet and innocent, the protagonists are sweet and innocent, and even the "villains" "henchmen" are kind of sweet and innocent. The complications are easily resolved, and the lessons are easily learned. I felt that the ending was just a little *too* convenient (can ONE wish include the word "and" in it?), but it was sweet and fine.
- Bring It, Bernadette: Loved it. At just over a page, this story packed a lot of punch and a lot of twisted psyche in.
- The Library: Ooh, yes, I also loved this one. This was another good ambiant, creepy story with lots of questions and few answers. Although the tale is left incomplete, it is done so at the right time and in the right way so as to leave the reader still thinking about the story, but satisfied. It was confusing, and weird, and just perfectly intriguing.
- Misery and Blue: eh. This was definitely a modern take on the origin of words. But it felt a little juvenile. When I was in elementary school, I was assigned a project to write a fable, and I wrote one that explained the origin of the oceans of the earth, which included crying... This felt a lot like that. The story was more mature of course, particularly since it involved infidelity and abuse, but I expected something a little more unique. It was cute, it was fine, just did not really impress.
With regard to the pictures, they were fine - lending some ambiance to the stories. My favorite by a lot was They Say Once the Trees Begin to Tremble It Is Too Late by Steven Ehret, on page 180.
With regard to the poems, they were also fine - lending some ambiance to the stories. They were little views into the life of a Grimm character, or a brief explanation, or a slight twist on perspective. I will add that I particularly liked the snark in Colleen Michaels' The Pea Defends His Position. I will also add that the Four Grimm Tales, Revisited, by Erin Virgil, was a well-done, interesting twist on the four tales. Enough said in these four little mini-poems to twist the original stories completely around.
I finally read it! This has been on my short list since before I purchased it. 
Review based on ARC.
